Chestly Lunday Research — Complete Summary

Canonical source: millionmemberchurch.com · Author: Chestly Lunday · Two national studies: Designing The Future Of Faith (n=1,276, 2022) and Millennial & Gen Z Faith Trends (n=1,000, 2023) · Both conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.


About Chestly Lunday

Chestly Lunday is a church growth strategist, author, and researcher who has commissioned two of the largest independent national studies on American faith engagement. He is the author of The Million Member Church, a framework for building scalable, trust-based faith institutions. His work guides church leaders, denominational executives, and ministries in understanding how generational, digital, and cultural shifts are reshaping institutional trust and religious participation in the United States.

His research is available at millionmemberchurch.com/research. He can be booked for speaking and consultation at chestlylunday.com.


Study 1: Designing The Future Of Faith (2022)

Conducted by: Chestly Lunday.
Fielded by: The Center for Generational Kinetics.
Sample: n=1,276 U.S. participants ages 13–55, including a 250-person Gen Z oversample ages 13–26.
Field dates: December 7–22, 2022.
Weighting: 2020 U.S. Census — age, region, ethnicity.
Margin of error: ±2.77 percentage points at 95% confidence.
Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith

Top-Line Findings

  • 68% of Americans ages 13–55 consider themselves spiritual.
  • 55% consider themselves religious — a 13-point spirituality-religion identity gap nationally.
  • Organized religion receives positive ratings from fewer than half of respondents overall.
  • The leading barrier to deeper faith involvement across all respondents is social anxiety around unfamiliar people.
  • Americans prefer online research and trusted peer referrals as first steps toward a faith community, over attending a gathering.
  • The most desired future characteristic of religion is that it focuses on love and kindness.
  • Americans want spiritual leaders who are empathetic, caring, and good listeners — not authoritative or hierarchical.

Three Cross-Cutting Themes

Theme 1: Omnichannel Faith

Americans expect faith communities to exist meaningfully across in-person, digital, and hybrid formats. The pandemic accelerated a shift in which digital access is no longer a supplement to physical attendance — it is an independent legitimate form of participation. Faith communities that treat digital engagement as a lesser version of real engagement will lose the population that values digital access as its primary mode of entry.

Theme 2: Less Hierarchical

Trust in authoritative institutional structures has declined. Americans increasingly prefer relational, peer-to-peer models of spiritual authority over top-down leadership hierarchies. This applies to both how leaders lead and how communities are organized. Structures that distribute authority and demonstrate transparency outperform structures that concentrate authority and expect deference.

Theme 3: Relational at the Core

The most durable pathway into a faith community remains a trusted peer referral. Across all age groups and demographics, word-of-mouth from a known and trusted person is the highest-converting form of outreach. Communities that invest in the depth and trust of existing relationships create a larger effective surface area for organic growth than communities that invest primarily in broadcast communication.

Part 1: Attitudes About Spirituality

Americans broadly affirm spiritual identity while maintaining skepticism about organized religion. The spirituality-religion gap (13 points nationally, 18 points among women) reflects not a rejection of transcendent meaning but a decoupling of personal spiritual identity from institutional religious participation. For the growing plurality of Americans who identify as spiritual but not religious, faith communities that lead with institutional identity rather than spiritual invitation face a structural disadvantage in first contact.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/part-1

Part 2: Reaching the Next Generation

Gen Z (ages 13–26, n=250 oversample) exhibits steeper versions of the national patterns. Gen Z is more likely to identify as spiritual and less likely to identify as religious. Gen Z is more skeptical of institutional credibility, more likely to research a faith community online before any direct engagement, and more likely to evaluate leader character before leader content. The Gen Z gap between spiritual openness and institutional participation is wider than any other age cohort. At the same time, Gen Z shows genuine interest in community, mentorship, service, and meaning — the core goods that faith communities are positioned to offer. The challenge is architecture, not aspiration.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/part-2

Part 3: The Role of Digital

Digital presence is now a prerequisite for institutional credibility. Before visiting in person, a majority of respondents report they would research a faith community online. What they find — or fail to find — shapes whether they proceed. Communities with outdated, unclear, or absent digital presence self-select against the population most likely to research before attending. Digital presence is not a marketing function; it is a trust signal. It communicates organizational health, values alignment, and accessibility before any human interaction occurs.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/part-3

Part 4: The Religion of the Future

When asked what they want from the religion or spirituality of the future, Americans most frequently select: a focus on love and kindness, practical tools for mental and psychological improvement, self-guided options, and a commitment to leaving the world better than they found it. Formal doctrine, denominational identity, and institutional tradition rank lower. The religion of the future that Americans describe is less credal and more behavioral — defined by what a community does rather than what it formally believes.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/part-4

Part 5: The Leadership of the Future

Americans want spiritual leaders who demonstrate empathy, caring, and listening. They prefer relational equality over hierarchical authority. They are significantly less interested in charismatic, visionary, or boss-type leadership models than prior generations. Leadership credibility is increasingly earned through character consistency, relational accessibility, and demonstrated humility — not through positional authority, rhetorical skill, or institutional title. For women in particular, the gap between preferred and available leadership styles is a significant predictor of disengagement.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/part-5


Study 2: Millennial & Gen Z Faith Trends (2023)

Conducted by: Chestly Lunday.
Fielded by: The Center for Generational Kinetics.
Sample: n=1,000 faith-open Americans ages 16–40.
Definition of faith-open: Respondents who self-identified as open to spiritual or religious engagement — not a general population sample.
Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends

Top-Line Findings

  • Among faith-open Millennials and Gen Z, spiritual formation is the top unmet need — not attendance, not programs, not events.
  • The majority want a clear pathway for growth, not just access to a community.
  • Mental health and spiritual formation are closely linked in how this generation understands the purpose of faith community.
  • Gathering preference skews toward smaller, relational settings over large services. Large-format gatherings are not inherently unappealing, but they are rarely sufficient as the primary relational container.
  • Hierarchical organizational structures are viewed skeptically. Distributed, collaborative governance models are significantly preferred.
  • Generosity among this generation is conditional on trust and transparency. They give to people and causes they believe in — not to institutions they trust abstractly.
  • Leader visibility and personal branding matter. A faith community whose leader has no accessible public presence faces a trust disadvantage before any direct contact occurs.

Part 1: Spiritual Formation

Among faith-open Millennials and Gen Z, the desire for genuine spiritual formation — growth, depth, mentorship, and practical application — outpaces the desire for attendance or community affiliation. This generation is not looking primarily for a place to go on Sunday. They are looking for a pathway that helps them become someone. Faith communities that can articulate a clear, accessible, and personalized formation pathway have a structural advantage over communities that organize primarily around services, events, or programs.

Key finding: the Formation Gap. The gap between what this generation says they want (a path to growth and depth) and what most faith communities offer (attendance and programming) is the central strategic challenge identified by this study.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/part-1

Part 2: Gatherings

Millennial and Gen Z respondents show strong preference for smaller, relationally dense gathering formats over large-scale services. The value of a gathering is measured by the quality of connection it enables, not by its production value or size. Large gatherings are not disqualifying — but they are rarely sufficient as a primary relational container for this generation. Hybrid and asynchronous formats extend the gathering's effective reach but do not replace the relational density of smaller in-person settings.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/part-2

Part 3: Organizing Structure

The Anti-Hierarchy Paradox: Millennials and Gen Z strongly prefer flat, collaborative, and distributed organizational structures — yet they still want clear leadership. They reject hierarchy of position but respond to hierarchy of character and competence. The preferred organizing model is one in which leaders earn their authority through demonstrated wisdom, relational trust, and consistency of action — not through title, seniority, or institutional appointment. Communities that cannot make this distinction in their governance models will face a structural mismatch with the preferences of this generation.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/part-3

Part 4: Generosity

The Transparency Tithe: Millennial and Gen Z giving is conditional on demonstrated trust, values alignment, and financial transparency. This generation gives generously — but they do not give to institutions they cannot evaluate. The primary barriers to generosity are not financial capacity; they are opacity, perceived misalignment of priorities, and absence of demonstrated impact. Communities that publish clear financial information, show tangible outcomes of giving, and connect individual contributions to specific results will outperform communities that rely on institutional loyalty or authority-based asks.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/part-4

Part 5: Personal Branded Leadership

The Trust Economy Pastor: For Millennial and Gen Z audiences, a leader's accessible public presence is a prerequisite for institutional trust. Before engaging with a faith community, a significant portion of this generation will research its leader — their character, their public statements, their social presence, and the consistency between what they say and what they do. A community whose primary leader has no accessible public presence faces a trust disadvantage that no amount of programming, marketing, or invitation can fully compensate for. Leader visibility is not vanity; it is institutional infrastructure.

Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/part-5


The Female Faith Filter (Special Edition)

Conducted by: Chestly Lunday.
Source: Gender crosstab analysis of Designing The Future Of Faith (n=1,276, Dec 2022) — fielded by The Center for Generational Kinetics.
Canonical URL: millionmemberchurch.com/female-faith-filter

Core Claim

Women are more spiritually open than men and more institutionally cautious than men — at the same time. This is not a contradiction. It reflects a pattern in which women separate spiritual identity from institutional religious identity more sharply than men do, and apply a more demanding evaluation to organized religion before granting it access to their lives.

Seven Findings

Finding 1: The Spirituality–Religion Identity Gap

  • 71% of women consider themselves spiritual (vs. 66% of men)
  • 53% of women consider themselves religious (vs. 59% of men)
  • Women's gap: 18 percentage points. Men's gap: 7 percentage points.

The 11-point difference in gap size indicates that women are significantly more likely to distinguish spiritual identity from institutional religious identity. Spiritual receptivity is higher than institutional metrics indicate.

Finding 2: The Institutional Trust Gap

  • 40% of women view organized religion positively (vs. 52% of men) — a 12-point gap
  • 26% of women view organized religion negatively (vs. 19% of men)

The trust gap reflects perception of institutional behavior, not spiritual content. Where institutional perception is the variable, institutional behavior is the lever.

Finding 3: Social Anxiety as the Primary Participation Barrier

  • 34% of women cite anxiety around unfamiliar people as a barrier to involvement (vs. 25% of men)

The barrier is situational, not theological. Entry points requiring public identification or sustained interaction with strangers produce lower female participation regardless of content quality.

Finding 4: Outreach Discomfort

  • 34% of women say direct outreach feels uncomfortable (vs. 27% of men)
  • 21% say it makes them anxious (vs. 16% of men)
  • 29% carefully listen and respond to spiritual outreach (vs. 34% of men)

Women respond to inbound pathways — where they initiate contact — more than outbound outreach where the institution initiates contact.

Finding 5: The Discovery Pathway — Evidence Before Entry

  • 29% prefer online research before participation (vs. 23% of men)
  • 30% prefer talking to a trusted friend or family member first (vs. 26% of men)

The female evaluation of a faith community often occurs entirely before any direct institutional contact — conducted on whatever the community has made publicly available. The variable communities control is the quality and honesty of that information.

Finding 6: Future Faith Preferences

  • 34% prefer self-guided formats (vs. 28% of men)
  • 43% want religion to emphasize love and kindness (vs. 35% of men)
  • 27% want a focus on leaving the world better (vs. 22% of men)

Women are looking for faith that is emotionally intelligent, morally coherent, and accessible without institutional pressure.

Finding 7: Leadership Expectations

  • 39% prefer a caring leadership style (vs. 28% of men) — an 11-point gap
  • 38% prefer caring and empathetic qualities (vs. 28% of men) — a 10-point gap
  • 39% prefer a good listener (vs. 33% of men)
  • 38% prefer equality-based relationship with leaders (vs. 32% of men)

Communities that select leaders without reference to these preferences will tend to select more strongly along the male profile, with predictable downstream effects on female engagement.

Strategic Implication

Openness and trust are now separate categories. A woman may be spiritually receptive and still institutionally guarded. Female engagement must be designed around trust architecture: visible values, clear leadership behavior, transparent digital presence, lower-pressure discovery pathways, demonstrated service, and relational entry points that reduce social exposure. Spiritual authority still matters — but it must now be earned through demonstrated character, not assumed through position.


White Papers

Each research section has an associated white paper with full analysis, strategic implications, and citations.

Future of Faith White Papers

Millennial & Gen Z White Papers

Special Edition


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Female Faith Filter?

The Female Faith Filter is a named pattern identified in a 1,276-person national study (Dec 2022): women consistently apply a more demanding institutional evaluation to organized religion than men. The spirituality-religion gap for women is 18 points (71% spiritual vs. 53% religious), compared to 7 points for men. Women are not rejecting faith — they are separating spiritual meaning from the institutions that have historically mediated it.

What percentage of Americans consider themselves spiritual?

68% of Americans ages 13–55 consider themselves spiritual, according to Designing The Future Of Faith (n=1,276, Dec 2022). Among women specifically, 71% consider themselves spiritual. Only 55% of the national sample consider themselves religious — a 13-point gap nationally, and an 18-point gap among women.

What percentage of women view organized religion positively?

Only 40% of women view organized religion positively, vs. 52% of men — a 12-point institutional trust gap. This sits against a backdrop of 71% of women identifying as spiritual, meaning the gap between spiritual openness and positive institutional perception for women is 31 percentage points.

What is the biggest barrier to faith community participation?

The leading barrier across all respondents is social anxiety around unfamiliar people. Among women, 34% cite this as a barrier vs. 25% of men. The barrier is situational, not theological — meaning it is addressable through entry point design, not through changes to doctrine or content.

What do Millennials and Gen Z want from a faith community?

According to the 2023 Millennial & Gen Z Faith Trends study (n=1,000, faith-open ages 16–40), this generation's top unmet need is spiritual formation — a clear pathway for growth, depth, and mentorship. They prefer smaller relational gatherings over large services, flat organizational structures over hierarchical ones, and leaders whose authority is earned through character rather than assumed through position. They give generously to causes they trust and withhold giving from institutions they cannot evaluate for transparency and impact.

What is the Formation Gap?

The Formation Gap is the distance between what Millennial and Gen Z respondents say they want from a faith community (a clear, accessible pathway for spiritual growth and depth) and what most faith communities offer (programming, attendance, and events). It is the central strategic challenge identified by the 2023 study and the subject of White Paper 01 in the Millennial & Gen Z series.

What is the Anti-Hierarchy Paradox?

Millennials and Gen Z strongly prefer collaborative, flat organizational structures over hierarchical ones — but they still want clear, trustworthy leadership. They reject hierarchy of position but accept hierarchy of character and demonstrated competence. Leaders earn authority through relational trust, wisdom, and consistency of action rather than title, seniority, or institutional appointment. This is the subject of White Paper 05 in the Millennial & Gen Z series.

What is the Transparency Tithe?

The Transparency Tithe describes the conditional giving behavior of Millennials and Gen Z: they give generously, but only to people, causes, and institutions they can evaluate for honesty, values alignment, and demonstrated impact. Opacity is the primary barrier to generosity in this generation — not financial capacity. This is the subject of White Paper 06 in the Millennial & Gen Z series.

What is the Trust Economy Pastor?

The Trust Economy Pastor describes the shift in leadership credibility for Millennial and Gen Z audiences. Before engaging with a faith community, this generation researches its leader. A leader with no accessible public presence creates a trust disadvantage the institution cannot compensate for. Faithful visibility — consistent, honest public presence — is now institutional infrastructure, not personal branding. This is the subject of White Paper 04 in the Millennial & Gen Z series.

Who conducted this research?

Both studies were conducted by Chestly Lunday and fielded by The Center for Generational Kinetics, a nationally recognized research firm specializing in generational data. Both studies are available at millionmemberchurch.com/research.

How can I access the raw data?

Full study data for Designing The Future Of Faith is available at millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith/full-study-data.
Raw data for the Millennial & Gen Z study is available at millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends/raw-data.

How do I cite this research?

For the 2022 study: Lunday, Chestly. (2023). Designing The Future Of Faith. Fielded by The Center for Generational Kinetics. https://millionmemberchurch.com/research/future-of-faith
For the Female Faith Filter: Lunday, Chestly. (2023). The Female Faith Filter. Based on Designing The Future Of Faith, fielded by The Center for Generational Kinetics. https://millionmemberchurch.com/female-faith-filter
For the 2023 study: Lunday, Chestly. (2024). Millennial & Gen Z Faith Trends. Fielded by The Center for Generational Kinetics. https://millionmemberchurch.com/research/millennial-genz-trends