Back to Millennial & Gen Z Trends
White Paper 01 · Millennial & Gen Z Trends SeriesChestly Lunday · 2023 · n=1,000 faith-open Americans ages 16–40

The Formation
Gap

Why Millennials and Gen Z Want Faith That Gives Them a Path, Not Just a Place

By Chestly Lunday — An analytical white paper based on Millennial & Gen Z Trends Driving Faith Community Engagement, conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The Formation Gap at a Glance

91%
would prefer to gather with Christians at least monthly
57%
would prefer to gather weekly or more often
80%
say real-life challenges are important in spiritual formation
79%
say clear next steps to grow in faith are important
75%
say spiritual support groups are important
74%
want a customized pathway based on learning interests

Executive Summary

From Place-Based Faith to Pathway-Based Faith

Millennial and Gen Z faith engagement is often interpreted through the categories of attendance, content preference, worship style, or digital access. Those categories matter, but they do not reach the center of the data. This study points to something deeper: young faith-open adults want Christian community to function as a formation pathway, not only a place to attend.

The study's sample is already meaningful: 1,000 Americans ages 16–40 who are interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community. Within that population, the appetite for gathering remains strong. Ninety-one percent would prefer to gather with other Christians at least monthly, and 57% would prefer to gather weekly or more often.

The strategic implication is significant. Faith communities that treat engagement as attendance alone will under-read the moment. The data indicates that the emerging engagement standard is formation credibility: whether a community can help young adults grow in ways that are spiritually meaningful, emotionally relevant, relationally supported, and practically visible.

What the Data Shows

The Gathering Appetite

  • →91% want to gather at least monthly
  • →57% want to gather weekly or more often
  • →88% are current believers in the Christian faith
  • →60% are active in their Christian faith

What the Data Also Shows

The Formation Demand

  • →80% want real-life challenges in their formation
  • →79% want clear next steps to grow
  • →75% want spiritual support groups
  • →74% want customized pathways

The Full Analysis

Seven Key Findings

Click each section to expand the full analysis.

01

The Core Engagement Question Is Shifting from Place to Path

Click to read

02

Clear Next Steps Are a Formation Requirement, Not a Program Preference

Click to read

03

Real-Life Application Is the Strongest Formation Signal

Click to read

04

Support Structures Matter Because Formation Is Relational

Click to read

05

Customization Is Becoming a Trust Signal

Click to read

06

Formation Extends Through Family, Leaders, Friends, and Mentors

Click to read

07

The Formation Gap Is Also a Relevance Gap

Click to read

For Faith Leaders & Communicators

7 Strategic Implications

1

Build formation pathways, not just programs

Attendance is not formation. Design a visible path from curiosity to practice to maturity — with clear next steps at every stage.

2

Make the next step impossible to miss

79% want clear next steps. Every gathering, sermon, and digital touchpoint should make it obvious what someone does next to keep growing.

3

Close the teaching-to-practice gap

80% want real-life challenges. Formation that stays conceptual loses credibility. Build exercises, commitments, and practices into every formation pathway.

4

Design for autonomy and accompaniment together

75% value spiritual support groups even in self-guided contexts. Formation is personal, but it is not solitary. Build in mentors, peers, and guides.

5

Offer multiple formation pathways

74% want customized pathways. Theological coherence does not require programmatic uniformity. Meet people at different life stages with different routes.

6

Equip formation agents beyond the stage

Faith leaders are one of five major formation contributors. Equip parents, mentors, friends, and small-group leaders to be credible formation agents.

7

Lead with relevance — then go deep

Millennials and Gen Z want both substance and application. Lead with the existential questions they are actually asking, then offer the theological depth that answers them.

Conclusion

The Future Belongs to Communities That Can Form People

The Formation Gap describes a generation that is not abandoning Christian community. It describes a generation that is waiting for Christian community to become formative.

The good news is that the appetite for gathering is strong. Young faith-open adults want to meet regularly, connect with others, and grow in their faith. The challenge is that gathering alone is no longer sufficient. They are looking for communities that can give them a route — from belief to practice, from curiosity to growth, from participation to lived formation.

The future belongs to faith communities that can form people — not just host them. The communities that close the formation gap will earn the loyalty, engagement, and generosity of the next generation.

Methodology & Source Notes

This white paper analyzes Millennial & Gen Z Trends Driving Faith Community Engagement, conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The study included 1,000 U.S. participants ages 16–40 who were interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community. The survey was fielded August 11–24, 2023, weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, gender, and ethnicity, and has a reported margin of error of ±3.1 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.

Unless otherwise noted, all percentages cited in this paper refer to the Study #2 sample: young Americans ages 16–40 who are interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community. This sampling frame differs from the broader general-population study used in the first white paper series and should not be statistically blended with it.

Ready to Apply These Findings?

Explore the full study data, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.