Back to Research Hub
National Research Study · Study 2 of 2Chestly Lunday · September 2023 · n=1,000 faith-open Americans ages 16–40

Millennial &
Gen Z Trends
Driving Faith Community Engagement

Study 1 Revealed The Gap. This Study Names Who's In It.

This study zooms in on faith-open Gen Z and Millennials across varying engagement levels to understand what they are moving towards — not just what they believe. The segmentation by faith engagement reveals the trajectory of faith community participation in the present and near future.

1,000
Americans Surveyed
Sept. 2023
Field Date
5
Research Sections
Free
Public Access

The Headline Finding

Belief Is High — But Active Engagement Is The Gap

88%
are current Believers in Christian faith
vs.
28-point gap
60%
are Active in their Christian faith

The gap between belief and active participation is the mission field every church leader must understand. Young Americans believe — the challenge is creating communities worthy of their engagement.

Research Methodology

Who We Studied

Unlike broad national studies on faith, this research focused exclusively on Americans aged 16–40 who are already interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community. This unique filter produces dramatically more actionable data for church leaders and ministry strategists.

By studying faith-open individuals rather than the general public, we could ask deeper questions about what would actually drive engagement, generosity, and commitment — rather than simply measuring who already attends.

The result is a rare dataset: the preferences, fears, motivations, and expectations of the people most likely to be reached by your church or ministry in the next decade.

The Faith-Open Filter

Every respondent was already interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community — making this the most actionable young-adult faith dataset available.

Generational Breakdown

Younger Gen Z (Ages 16–21) — 17%
Older Gen Z (Ages 22–26) — 22%
Younger Millennials (Ages 27–35) — 38%
Older Millennials (Ages 36–40) — 23%

Key Story Elements We Uncovered

Three Cross-Cutting Themes

These narratives run through all five sections of the study. Click to expand the supporting data.

01

Young Americans Are Open — But Their Preferences Are Strong & Diverse

Young Americans open to Christian faith communities are interested in expanding their spirituality and faith in a variety of novel ways.

Click to see the supporting data

02

Gen Z and Millennials Are Two Distinct Audiences

Each generation's Christian faith has been influenced by very different sources and they have very different preferences for how they gather, give, and lead.

Click to see the supporting data

03

Transparency & Personal Connection Drive Generosity

Young faith-open Americans would be more likely to give to a faith community if they knew specifically how the money would be used and how it will benefit the local community.

Click to see the supporting data

Explore The Data

Five Research Sections

Each section examines a critical dimension of faith engagement among Millennials and Gen Z.

Top-Line Findings

Key Research Discoveries

88%

are current believers in the Christian faith and 60% are active in their Christian faith among young Americans open to getting involved in a faith community.

57%

would prefer to socialize, learn, and grow with other Christians once a week or more often.

66%

want a hybrid organizational structure — a clear leader who empowers others where they are gifted and passionate.

68%

think it is important for Christian faith leaders to use personal branding to reach and connect with young people.

81%

have given personal money to a charity or non-profit organization, showing existing generosity habits.

60%

say a charismatic faith leader draws them into a new Christian faith community more than the community itself.

#1

role faith leaders should play: lead by example. Listening to needs of members and modeling Christian behaviors follow closely behind.

49%

prefer in-person small groups (2–10 people) as their top preference for socializing, learning, and growing in their faith.

Research Scope

How This Study Complements Study 1

The first Sprout Digital study (Study 1) surveyed 1,276 Americans ages 13–55 to paint a broad landscape of belief, spirituality, and institutional trust in America today.

This study (Study 2) drills deeper — surveying 1,000 faith-open young Americans ages 16–40 to understand the specific drivers, preferences, and expectations of those most likely to engage with faith communities.

Together, these two studies form the most comprehensive picture available of how America's next generation relates to faith — and what it will take for churches and ministries to connect meaningfully with them.

The Forward-Looking Mandate

Understanding the preferences of those already open to faith is the fastest path to building communities that grow.

Compare The Two Studies

Study 1: 1,276 Americans, Ages 13–55 (General population)
Study 2: 1,000 Americans, Ages 16–40 (Faith-open only)
View Study 1: Designing The Future Of Faith →

Research Series

Millennial & Gen Z White Papers

Deep-dive analytical papers drawn from the national study data. Free to download.

White Paper 01

The Formation Gap

Why Millennials and Gen Z Want Faith That Gives Them a Path, Not Just a Place

91%
prefer to gather at least monthly
57%
prefer to gather weekly+
79%
want clear next steps
80%
want real-life challenges

Central Thesis

“The core engagement question is shifting from place to path.”

White Paper 02

The Mental Health Gospel

Why Emotional Wellness Is Becoming a Front Door to Christian Formation

31%
rank life planning top 3
30%
rank stress coping top 3
28%
want mental wellness coaching
Top 3
emotional wellness needs drive formation

Central Thesis

“Emotional wellness has become a front door to Christian formation.”

White Paper 03

Small Is the New Sacred

Why Millennials and Gen Z Want Christian Community at Human Scale

91%
want to gather monthly+
57%
want to gather weekly+
49%
prefer in-person small groups
43%
prefer one-on-one mentorship

Central Thesis

“Human scale is not a stylistic preference. It is a trust condition.”

White Paper 04

The Trust Economy Pastor

Why the Faith Leader Is Now the On-Ramp to the Community

68%
say personal branding is important for faith leaders
73%
of younger Gen Z say leader branding is important
60%
drawn more by the leader than the community
51%
choose between communities based on leader's brand

Central Thesis

“Personal brand is not about platform. It is about pre-participation trust.”

White Paper 05

The Anti-Hierarchy Paradox

Why Young Faith-Open Adults Want Less Control — But Not Less Clarity

66%
prefer hybrid structure
62%
prefer representative structure
60%
prefer flat structure
47%
value equal voice as top advantage

Central Thesis

“The future is not less structure. It is better trusted structure.”

White Paper 06

The Transparency Tithe

Why Millennials and Gen Z Give When They Can See the Impact

77%
have given to a church or faith community
71%
most likely to give anonymously
65%
respond to microdonations that reduce guilt
39%
give more when they know how money will be used

Central Thesis

“They are not anti-generosity. They are anti-vague generosity.”

Citation Guidelines

Using This Research

This data is public — you are welcome to share individual stats and small groups of data in presentations, podcasts, radio shows, reports, articles, and blog posts. We ask that you cite us both ways:

Cite As

"Millennial & Gen Z Faith Trends National Research Study by Chestly Lunday (September 2023)"

Send Audiences To

Direct your audience to millionmemberchurch.com/research — do not forward the PDF directly.

Methodology

→Commissioned by Chestly Lunday and Strategic Partners
→Custom 25-question online survey, fielded August 11–24, 2023
→1,000 U.S. participants ages 16–40, interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community
→Weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, gender, and ethnicity
→Margin of error ±3.1 percentage points at the 95% confidence level
→All percentages statistically significant at the 95% confidence level unless noted

Ready to Engage The Next Generation?

Explore the full study data online, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.