Back to Millennial & Gen Z Trends
White Paper 06 · Millennial & Gen Z Trends SeriesChestly Lunday · 2023 · n=1,000 faith-open Americans ages 16–40

The Transparency
Tithe

Why Millennials and Gen Z Give When They Can See the Impact

By Chestly Lunday — An analytical white paper based on Millennial & Gen Z Trends Driving Faith Community Engagement, conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The Transparency Tithe at a Glance

77%
have given personal money to a church, religious group, or faith community
71%
are likely to participate in anonymous donations — the highest giving behavior tested
65%
are likely to participate in microdonations that reduce guilt about not having enough
53%
have given a tithe to a church, religious group, or faith community
39%
say knowing specifically how money will be used would make them more likely to give
38%
name seeing others truly in need as a top-three influence on giving

Central Thesis

They Are Not Anti-Generosity. They Are Anti-Vague Generosity.

Generosity may be one of the most practical and misunderstood findings in Millennial & Gen Z Trends Driving Faith Community Engagement. Churches often worry that younger adults are less willing to give, less loyal to institutions, or less committed to the financial life of a faith community. The study points to a more useful interpretation: young faith-open adults are already generous, but they evaluate giving through a different trust framework than many churches assume.

The generosity question for churches is therefore not only, Will Millennials and Gen Z give? The sharper question is, Can the church create a generosity culture that is credible enough for them to trust?

Young faith-open adults will give when churches make generosity specific, visible, low-shame, trustworthy, and connected to real human impact. The future of church giving will be sustained less by pressure and more by clarity, credibility, and evidence of good.

What the Data Shows

Generosity Is Already Present

  • →81% have given to a charity or nonprofit
  • →77% have given to a church or faith community
  • →61% gave to a church in the past year
  • →53% have given a tithe

What the Data Also Shows

Trust Conditions Govern the Gift

  • →39% need to know specifically how money will be used
  • →43% less likely to give when they feel pressured
  • →41% less likely when asked too frequently
  • →35% cite seeing direct impact as a top motivator

The Full Analysis

Seven Key Findings

Click each section to expand the full analysis.

01

The Giving Problem Is Not Willingness; It Is Trust

Click to read

02

Generosity Is Already Present in This Audience

Click to read

03

Tithing Remains Meaningful, But It Is Not the Only Doorway

Click to read

04

Anonymous Giving Reveals a Show-No-Show Impulse

Click to read

05

Microdonations Reduce the Shame Barrier

Click to read

06

Specificity and Impact Clarity Are the Strongest Giving Motivators

Click to read

07

Pressure and Performative Giving Culture Are the Strongest Giving Suppressors

Click to read

For Faith Leaders & Communicators

7 Strategic Implications

1

Start with the truth: they already give

77% have given to a church or faith community. Don't begin generosity conversations with scarcity or pressure. Begin with gratitude and affirmation of the generosity that already exists.

2

Build a generosity ecosystem, not a single ask

Offer multiple on-ramps: anonymous giving, microdonations, crowdfunding, matching gifts, member-need giving. Not every young adult's generosity journey begins with the tithe — but many will arrive there.

3

Make anonymous giving easy and honorable

71% are most likely to give anonymously. Remove barriers to anonymous generosity. Do not treat it as second-class. Build systems and theology that honor giving without requiring recognition.

4

Eliminate shame from your giving culture

65% respond to microdonation language designed to reduce guilt. Remove shame language, income-percentage pressure, and public comparison from your giving culture. Honor every gift at every level.

5

Lead with specificity, not with general appeals

39% say knowing how money will be used would increase their giving. Replace 'give to support our ministry' with specific stories, named needs, clear budgets, and measurable outcomes.

6

Show impact consistently and honestly

35% cite seeing a direct impact as a top giving motivator. Create regular impact reporting — not just budget reports — that shows real human outcomes from the community's generosity.

7

Redesign how and how often you ask

43% are less likely to give when they feel pressured, and 41% when asked too frequently. Reduce pressure, space your appeals, remove performative elements, and communicate need with honesty rather than urgency.

Conclusion

The Future of Giving Is Clarity, Not Pressure

The Transparency Tithe describes a generation that has not lost the capacity for generosity. It describes a generation that has raised the trust threshold for generosity. Young faith-open adults will give — but they will give to communities that can answer the question: Can we show you exactly what your gift will do?

The communities that earn their generosity will not be the communities with the most sophisticated fundraising software or the most emotionally compelling campaigns. They will be the communities that have built a culture of financial transparency, impact visibility, low-shame on-ramps, and genuine pastoral care around money.

The question is not whether Millennials and Gen Z will give. The question is whether faith communities will create the trust conditions under which their generosity can flourish. The data suggests that many communities are one decision away from unlocking a generation of generous disciples — the decision to stop asking for more, and start showing more.

Methodology & Source Notes

This white paper analyzes Millennial & Gen Z Trends Driving Faith Community Engagement, commissioned by Chestly Lunday and Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital and conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The study used a custom 25-question online survey completed by 1,000 U.S. participants ages 16–40 who were interested in or open to getting involved in a Christian faith community. The survey was fielded August 11–24, 2023, and weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, gender, and ethnicity. The reported margin of error is ±3.1 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.

Source base for this paper: raw crosstabs for generosity-related questions and the Future of Faith media-ready statistics brief. The data should not be generalized to all Americans or all young adults; it should be read as a focused analysis of the audience most open to Christian faith community.

Ready to Apply These Findings?

Explore the full study data, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.