Back to Future of Faith
White Paper 03 · Future of Faith SeriesChestly Lunday · December 2022 · n=1,276

Curious but
Cautious

Why Americans Are Still Open to Faith — But Only on New Terms

By Chestly Lunday — An analytical white paper based on Designing The Future Of Faith, a national research study Commissioned By Chestly Lunday and his Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital.

The Permission Problem at a Glance

62%
would be interested in a group aligned with their values
1 in 3
feel curiosity when a spiritual or religious group reaches out
31%
carefully listen to or read a message and respond
65%
would be more interested if the group helped others in need
68%
wish spiritual and religious groups were more tolerant
30%
cite anxiety around unknown people as top barrier

Executive Summary

Openness Is Conditional

Designing The Future Of Faith complicates the assumption that the American public is simply closed to religious or spiritual groups. The study found that 62% of Americans would be interested in learning more about a spiritual or religious group that aligned with their values. That is not a small opening. It is a majority-level signal that the public is still reachable when the terms of engagement feel credible.

The outreach data reinforces the point. When a spiritual or religious group reaches out about involvement, curiosity is the most prevalent feeling, named by one in three Americans. Thirty-one percent say they carefully listen to or read the message and respond. Those findings should change the tone of faith strategy. The issue is not only that people are not hearing. The issue is whether the invitation feels trustworthy enough to consider.

The pathway forward is not simply better advertising. Americans prefer relational entry points, especially in-person discussions with a friend who is already involved. The data indicates that Americans are still open to faith. The question is whether faith communities are prepared to earn the right to be heard.

What's Possible

The Opportunity

  • →62% interested in groups aligned with their values
  • →1 in 3 feel curiosity when reached out to
  • →31% carefully listen and respond to messages
  • →People prefer relational, not broadcast entry

What Blocks It

The Barriers

  • →30% experience anxiety around unknown people
  • →60% of Gen Z want teaching more relevant to their lives
  • →68% wish faith groups were more tolerant
  • →Values alignment must come before deeper commitment

The Full Analysis

Seven Key Findings

Click each section to expand the full analysis.

01

The Myth of the Closed Audience

Click to read

02

Values Alignment Is the New Front Door

Click to read

03

The Emotional Cost of Entry

Click to read

04

Relevance Is a Threshold Requirement for Gen Z

Click to read

05

The Path Is Relational First, Then Digital

Click to read

06

Service Is the Clearest Credibility Signal

Click to read

07

Tolerance Is a Posture, Not a Theological Concession

Click to read

For Faith Leaders & Communicators

7 Strategic Implications

1

Lead with values, not programs

The first impression task is not to describe programs or explain theology. It is to make values visible and clear. Show through tone, through community practices, and through how people treat each other what the group actually cares about.

2

Design for anxiety, not indifference

Because 30% cite anxiety around strangers as the top barrier, hospitality design must lower emotional cost. Create transparent expectations, explain norms, welcome confusion, reduce the fear of judgment, and design first steps for people who have never been before.

3

Make relevance structural, not cosmetic

For Gen Z especially, teaching has to connect to real questions they carry: identity, purpose, anxiety, relationships, morality, the future. Relevance cannot be a wrapper around unchanged content. It has to be embedded in the substance.

4

Invest in relational ambassadors

Because people prefer relational entry points, the relational depth of your existing community is your primary outreach asset. Invest in people who will make genuine invitations, not only in campaigns that make announcements.

5

Use digital as verification, not as first contact

Digital content should reward investigation. Make leaders approachable in video. Show the community's actual culture. Answer newcomer questions. Make the first step feel navigable rather than risky.

6

Tell service stories specifically and repeatedly

Because 65% are more interested if they know the group serves, publicize service visibly and specifically. Service is not a side program. It is a primary credibility signal and should be told as such.

7

Separate conviction from harshness

The 68% tolerance wish does not require diluted faith. It requires warmth with conviction. Groups can hold strong beliefs while being kind about tone, genuinely curious about different perspectives, and respectful toward people still exploring.

Conclusion

Permission Is the Strategic Work

The future of faith does not belong to institutions that can be loudest, largest, or most culturally familiar. It belongs to institutions that can earn permission: demonstrated values, relational safety, practical relevance, visible service, and a posture that lowers the cost of taking a first step.

This is not a request for weaker faith or diluted theology. It is a strategic reality: the conditions for getting a fair hearing have changed. Institutions that treat earning permission as peripheral to their work will continue to see declining engagement. Institutions that treat permission as the central strategic work may find a reachable, curious, cautious public that is willing to explore.

The data shows that Americans are still open to faith. The question is whether faith communities are prepared to earn the right to be heard.

Methodology & Source Notes

Designing The Future Of Faith was commissioned by Chestly Lunday and Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital and conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The study used a custom 30-question online survey completed by 1,276 U.S. participants ages 13–55, including a 250-person oversample of Gen Z ages 13–26. The survey was fielded December 7–22, 2022, and weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, and ethnicity. The reported margin of error is ±2.77 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.

This is a cross-sectional study, not a longitudinal trend line. The sample covers Americans ages 13–55 and does not include Americans older than 55.

Ready to Apply These Findings?

Explore the full study data, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.