Back to Study Overview
Part 5 of 5Designing The Future Of Faith National Research Study · Chestly Lunday · Dec. 2022 · n=1,276

Leadership
Of The Future

What qualities, styles, and relationship models do Americans want in their spiritual leaders? The data reveals a dramatic generational divide — and a clear blueprint.

The Headline Finding

67% of Americans say faith groups need young people in leadership to reach young people.

And 63% of younger Gen Z find current spiritual leaders intimidating. The demand for young, approachable, honest leadership isn't just a preference — it's the primary access point for the next generation.

Key Findings (click to expand)

38%
want leaders who are honest and candid — the #1 quality
67%
say young people in leadership would help reach young people
63%
of younger Gen Z say spiritual leaders are often intimidating
34%
prefer Inspirational and Caring leadership styles
36%
want a close friend or family-type relationship with a leader
35%
of Gen Z want leaders who are willing to adapt

Most Appealing Qualities

(% ranking in top 3)

Honest and candid
38%
A good listener
36%
Caring and empathetic
33%
Willing to adapt
29%
Committed to continued growth
25%
Showing strength and resilience
22%
Ability to define a clear vision
21%

Agnostics value honesty and candor even more than other groups.

Most Appealing Styles

(% ranking in top 3)

Inspirational (helps and motivates)
34%
Caring (focused on feelings/group dynamics)
34%
Inclusive (involves everyone in decisions)
29%
Casual (laid back and confident)
26%
Collaborative (actively asking for feedback)
25%
Example-setting (sets standards by own actions)
23%

Gen Z rates Collaborative and Results-based styles significantly higher than older generations.

Preferred Relationship Type With a New Leader

36%
Close friend or family member
35%
Based on equality and balance
32%
Casual friends
23%
Teacher-Student
22%
Mentor-Protégé
22%
Parent-Child

Key insight: Americans want a peer or friend relationship with their spiritual leaders — not a parent, teacher, or authority figure. The traditional positional model of pastoral authority is losing ground with every generation tested.