Why Organized Religion Has a Trust Problem in America
By Chestly Lunday — An analytical white paper based on Designing The Future Of Faith, a national research study Commissioned By Chestly Lunday and his Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital.
The Trust Gap at a Glance
Executive Summary
The strongest finding in Designing The Future Of Faith is the gap between spirituality and organized religion. A large majority of Americans in the study believe in a higher power and consider themselves spiritual. But fewer consider themselves religious, and far fewer view organized religion positively than view spirituality positively.
That gap is the story. It suggests that the American public has not rejected the search for transcendence, meaning, purpose, comfort, moral grounding, or community. It has become more skeptical of the institutional packaging around those things. The reputational problem is specific — organized religion is associated with judgment, moral superiority, political divisiveness, control, and fear around believing the right things. Those are not minor communications problems. They are trust problems.
The opportunity is also specific. Sixty-two percent of Americans say they would be interested in learning more about a spiritual or religious group that aligned with their values. The next era of engagement will be won by rebuilding credibility — through relevance, tolerance, practical help, relational safety, digital competence, and younger leadership with real influence.
What America Still Believes
What Organized Religion Faces
The Full Analysis
Click each section to expand the full analysis.
Click to read
Click to read
Click to read
Click to read
Click to read
Click to read
Click to read
For Faith Leaders & Communicators
The data does not show an audience that owes organized religion its attention. It shows an audience willing to consider spirituality and religious community when credibility, values alignment, relevance, and relational safety are present.
Because 68% of Americans wish spiritual and religious groups were more tolerant, tolerance cannot be treated as a secondary communications theme. It is central to whether the public experiences a group as safe, fair, and credible.
Faith communities should not assume the public knows what they value. They have to show it plainly through language, priorities, service, leadership, and behavior.
Content should answer the questions cautious observers are actually asking: What is this group like? Who leads it? Will I be judged? Will I understand what is happening? Is this relevant to my life?
Anxiety around unknown people is the top barrier to deeper involvement. Small-group introductions, friend-led invitations, clear newcomer expectations, low-pressure learning sessions, and digital previews all matter.
A majority of Americans believe faith groups would better understand and reach young people if more young people had influence or leadership roles. Token visibility is not the same as authority.
65% of Americans would be more interested in getting involved with a spiritual or religious group if they knew it helped others in need. Public service cannot be a vague brand claim.
Conclusion
Designing The Future Of Faith does not describe a public that has outgrown faith. It describes a public that has become more demanding about who gets to represent faith. Spirituality is winning because it offers meaning with fewer institutional liabilities.
Organized religion still has deep assets — community, comfort, moral formation, continuity, service, and purpose. But those assets are weakened when the public associates the institution with judgment, superiority, political division, control, intimidation, or irrelevance.
The future of faith in America is not a contest between belief and unbelief. It is a contest between trusted meaning and distrusted institution. Organized religion does not need to become less serious to reach Americans. It needs to become more credible.
Methodology & Source Notes
Designing The Future Of Faith was commissioned by Chestly Lunday and Strategic Partners and conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.
The study used a custom 30-question online survey completed by 1,276 U.S. participants ages 13–55, including a 250-person oversample of Gen Z ages 13–26. The survey was fielded December 7–22, 2022, and weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, and ethnicity. The reported margin of error is ±2.77 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.
This is a cross-sectional study, not a longitudinal trend line. The sample covers Americans ages 13–55 and does not include Americans older than 55. Ranked top-three questions measure salience, not total agreement.
Explore the full study data, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.