Back to Future of Faith
White Paper 05 · Future of Faith SeriesChestly Lunday · December 2022 · n=1,276

After
Hierarchy

What Americans Actually Want from the Religion of the Future

By Chestly Lunday — An analytical white paper based on Designing The Future Of Faith, a national research study Commissioned By Chestly Lunday and his Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital.

Leadership Expectations at a Glance

67%
want younger leaders in their faith groups
63%
of Gen Z find spiritual leaders intimidating
74%
value honesty and candor in leaders
72%
want leaders who listen to their concerns

Executive Summary

The Future Belongs to Relational Leadership

The fifth paper in this series moves from diagnosis to design. The first four showed that spirituality outpaces religion, Gen Z splits into two faith futures, Americans remain open but guarded, and digital is now the front door. This paper asks: what kind of leadership can actually hold the future?

The answer is not leaderless spirituality or anti-community individualism. The answer is a demand for leadership that is closer, more honest, more emotionally safe, and less hierarchical. Americans—and Gen Z especially—are rejecting traditional hierarchical models. They are asking for leaders who are authentic, who listen, who admit limitations, and who share power with younger voices.

The future of leadership is not about less authority. It is about a different kind of authority: authority earned through relationship rather than assumed through position, authority built on honesty rather than projection of certainty, authority distributed across generations rather than concentrated at the top.

What's Wanted

The New Leadership

  • →Honesty about doubts, failures, and limitations
  • →Real listening capacity and genuine curiosity
  • →Emotional availability and empathetic response
  • →Willingness to share power with younger leaders

What's Failing

The Old Leadership

  • →Hierarchical distance and positional authority
  • →Projection of certainty and infallibility
  • →Single-authority structures with limited accountability
  • →Isolation of younger voices from real decision-making power

The Full Analysis

Seven Key Findings

Click each section to expand the full analysis.

01

The Leadership Question Has Changed

Click to read

02

The Qualities People Actually Want in Leaders

Click to read

03

Age and Authority Have a New Relationship

Click to read

04

Friendship Leadership Versus Functional Leadership

Click to read

05

Humility Is Now a Leadership Requirement

Click to read

06

The Accessibility Crisis Is a Leadership Crisis

Click to read

07

The Future Leader Is a Different Kind of Authority

Click to read

For Faith Leaders & Communicators

7 Strategic Implications

1

Begin experimenting with non-hierarchical governance and leadership structures

Single-authority models are increasingly ineffective. Develop leadership teams that include different ages, perspectives, and voices. Distribute decision-making power rather than concentrating it.

2

Develop younger leaders and give them meaningful authority and visibility

The 67% young-leadership finding is not cosmetic. Young people should help shape messaging, hospitality, digital content, service design, and strategic decisions—not just appear on stage.

3

Prioritize emotional intelligence and relational skills in leader development

Move beyond expertise and credentials. Train leaders in listening, empathy, self-awareness, and the capacity to create psychological safety in community.

4

Model vulnerability and honesty about doubts, struggles, and limitations

The honesty finding ranked at the top of desired leadership qualities. Leaders should be willing to admit when they do not know, when they have changed their mind, and when they are still learning.

5

Create accessibility—leaders should be approachable, not distant

63% of Gen Z find leaders intimidating. Create formats and spaces where people can interact with leaders informally, where questions are welcome, and where leaders are genuinely available.

6

Foster intergenerational leadership teams rather than single-authority models

Older leaders bring continuity and wisdom. Younger leaders bring cultural fluency and peer credibility. Both are necessary. Structure decision-making to require both voices.

7

Listen more than you speak; let people know their voices matter

Leaders who are known for their listening capacity gain more trust than leaders who are known for their speaking ability. Create mechanisms where people actually see their input changing decisions.

Conclusion

The Future of Leadership Is Relational

Twenty years of digital connectivity have reshaped what people want from authority figures. They no longer accept hierarchical distance. They want friendship. They want leaders who listen more than they speak. They want honesty about limitations. They want emotional safety. They want to see younger voices leading the way forward.

Faith communities that embrace this shift—moving from positional authority to relational leadership, from single voices to intergenerational teams, from control to conversation—will not only survive in the future. They will thrive.

The era of hierarchical religious authority has closed. The era of relational, authentic, emotionally intelligent leadership has begun. The strategic question for faith leaders is whether they will lead into that shift or resist it.

Methodology & Source Notes

Designing The Future Of Faith was commissioned by Chestly Lunday and Strategic Partners at Sprout Digital and conducted by The Center for Generational Kinetics.

The study used a custom 30-question online survey completed by 1,276 U.S. participants ages 13–55, including a 250-person oversample of Gen Z ages 13–26. The survey was fielded December 7–22, 2022, and weighted to the 2020 U.S. Census for age, region, and ethnicity. The reported margin of error is ±2.77 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.

This is a cross-sectional study, not a longitudinal trend line. The sample covers Americans ages 13–55 and does not include Americans older than 55.

Ready to Apply These Findings?

Explore the full study data, then book a call with Chestly to discuss how to apply these findings in your church or ministry context.